Q&A: Should I get a Belgian Tervuren or German Shepherd as a Personal Protection Dog?

Question by : Should I get a Belgian Tervuren or German Shepherd as a Personal Protection Dog?
I am going to buy a protection dog from one of the four breeds; German Shepherd, Belgian Tervuren, Doberman and Rottweiler. I have ruled out Rottweiler for the time being due to their stubborn nature. I have not completely ruled out Dobermans as my first protection dog, but i am leaning heavily in the direction of German Shepherd or Belgian Tervuren.
I am a very dominant person and I adore dogs. I want a dog who is very protective and handler sensative. I would like to find a dog that is enthusiastic about working with me. Based on my requirments and personality, which is the best fit?
Please no “Any dog will you protect you, even without training.” That is simply not true. Thanks.

Best answer:

Answer by Rodney Brock
I recommend a Belgian Tervuren. GSDs are great, but there are so many of them and they are so overbred!

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!

Belgian Sheepdog Puppy And Dog Information

Belgian Sheepdog Puppy And Dog Information

The Belgium Sheepdog is a beautiful, mostly black long haired dog that needs daily brushing. She is highly intelligent and makes a great watch dog. She is good with children but does not like rough play. As a reminder, never leave any young child unsupervised with a puppy or dog for any length of time. She needs plenty of exercise and a properly fenced in back yard is almost a must. She may do well with other pets, especially if she has been socialized with them at an early age.

*Approximate Adult Size. The approximate adult size (two years old or older) of the male Belgium Sheepdog is 24 to 26 inches high at the withers (highest point of the shoulder) and 65 to 75 pounds. Females range from 22 to 24 inches at the withers and 60 to 70 pounds.
*Special Health Considerations. All dog breeds have certain inherited health problems associated with that specific breed and the Belgium Sheepdog is no exception. Be on the lookout for epilepsy (common in dogs), eye problems, canine hip dysplasia (genetic based looseness in the hip joint that can lead to arthritis pain and lameness) and excessive shyness.
*Grooming. The Belgian Sheepdog has a long straight coat with an under coat. She should be brushed daily. She is a heavy shedder and brushing will help keep your house more free of shed hair. Brushing will help her maintain a clean and healthy coat and also help you keep a closer eye on her health and strengthen your emotional bond with your pet.
Her teeth should be brushed at least twice a week with toothpaste and toothbrush designed for dogs. Brushing removes the accumulation of plaque and tartar which can cause cavities (rarely) and periodontal disease. Dog periodontal disease can lead to pain, loss of teeth, bad breath and other serious disease.
Her toenails may need to be examined for growth and clipped regularly. The toenails of the rear feet grow slower than the toenails of the front feet. Generally a guillotine type trimmer is the best for this chore and competent instructions to accomplish this can be found on the net.
*Life Span. The dog can live between 13 and 14 years with proper nutrition, medical care and excellent living conditions.
*History. The Belgian Sheepdog was developed around the year 1885 in Groenendaal, Belgium as a flock guardian and protector of her master and his possessions.

Some Registries:
Belgium Sheepdog Club of America
UKC United Kennel Club
NKC National Kennel Club
CKC Continental Kennel Club
APRI Americas Pet Registry Inc.
AKC American Kennel Club
FCI Federation Cynologique Internationale
NZKC New Zealand Kennel Club
KCGB = Kennel Club of Great Britain
ANKC = Australian National Kennel Club
ACR = American Canine Registry

Litter Size: 6 to 10 Belgian Sheepdog puppies

Category: Herding,

Terms Too Describe. Intelligent, trustworthy, loyal, affectionate, alert, devotion, want to please,

*SPECIAL GOOD POINTS
Very intelligent.
Excellent watch dog.
She can stand cold weather well.
Beautiful.
*SPECIAL BAD POINTS
Heavy shedder, needs to brushed often if not daily.
Can be too aggressive.
Can be very shy.
They can be stressed when left alone.
Can tend to be one person dogs.
Professional training recommended.
Not for an inexperienced owner.
Can become destructive if bored.

*Other Names Known By: Chien de Berger Belge, Groenendael

Mitch Endick is a short article writer, editor and website developer for the popular pet site petpages.com.
www.petpages.com is a pet information site with free pet ads, dog classifieds, and puppy for sale info Petpages.com also offeres information on cats, fish, reptiles, birds, ferrets, rabbits, mice and even pet bugs.

Belgian Malinois Puppy And Dog Information

Belgian Malinois Puppy And Dog Information

The Belgian Malinois is a large intelligent dog that requires plenty of space. They are not suited to an apartment as they need a large properly fenced in enclosure to keep them exercised. They are an elegant well muscled dog, intelligent and eager to work. They will guard the family and make a great watchdog. They are good with older children but may not be good with your childrens friends. Just a reminder, never leave any young child unsupervised with a puppy or dog for any length of time. They may not take to other dogs and pets but can often be socialized to accept them.

*Approximate Adult Size. The approximate adult size (two years old or older) of the male Belgian Malinois is approximately 24 to 26 inches to the withers (highest point of the shoulder) and weigh about 65 to 75 pounds. Females are approximately 22 to 24 inches at the withers and weigh approximately 55 to 65 pounds.
*Special Health Considerations. All dog breeds have certain inherited health problems associated with that specific breed and the Belgian Malinois is no exception. Look for epilepsy (common in dogs), eye problems, canine hip dysplasia (genetic based looseness in the hip joint that can lead to arthritis pain and lameness) and excessive shyness.
*Grooming. The Belgian Malinois has an easy short hair coat. She should be bathed rarely as this strips her coat of its protective oils. She should be brushed at least weekly. She is a light shedder and brushing will help keep your house free of shed hair. Brushing will help her maintain a clean and healthy coat and also help you keep a closer eye on her health and strengthen your emotional bond with your pet.
Her teeth should be brushed at least twice a week with toothpaste and toothbrush designed for dogs. Brushing removes the accumulation of plaque and tartar which can cause cavities (rarely) and periodontal disease. Dog periodontal disease can lead to pain, loss of teeth, bad breath and other serious disease.
Her toenails may need to be examined for growth and clipped regularly. The toenails of the rear feet grow slower than the toenails of the front feet. Generally a guillotine type trimmer is the best for this chore and competent instructions to accomplish this can be found on the net.
*Life Span. The can live between 12 and 14 years with proper nutrition, medical care and excellent living conditions.
*History. The Belgian Malinois is a variety of the Belgian Shepherd dog from Belgium. The American Kennel Club recognized this breed on July 10, 1990. Today these dogs are used for military and police work because they are fast learners, willing to work, intelligent and aggressive.

Some Registries:
American Belgian Malinois Club
*UKC United Kennel Club
*NKC National Kennel Club
*CKC Continental Kennel Club
*APRI Americas Pet Registry Inc.
*AKC American Kennel Club
*FCI Federation Cynologique Internationale
*NZKC New Zealand Kennel Club
*KCGB = Kennel Club of Great Britain
*ANKC = Australian National Kennel Club
*ACR = American Canine Registry

Litter Size: 6 to 10 Belgian Malinois puppies.

Category: Herding, Sheepdog Family

Terms To Describe: Elegant, well muscled, proud, obedient, loyal,

*SPECIAL GOOD POINTS
Very intelligent.
Little grooming needed.
Responds well to commands.
Good with family children.
Very good watch dog.
Very good guard dog.
*SPECIAL BAD POINTS
Can be very aggressive.
Owner should be an experienced dog owner.
May not be good with your childrens friends.
Needs early proper training to curb aggressiveness.

*Other Names Known By: Malinois, Chien de Berger Belge

Mitch Endick is a short article writer, editor and website developer for the popular pet site petpages.com.
www.petpages.com is a pet information site with free pet ads, dog classifieds, and puppy for sale info Petpages.com also offeres information on cats, fish, reptiles, birds, ferrets, rabbits, mice and even pet bugs.

Belgian Tervuren Puppy And Dog Information

Belgian Tervuren Puppy And Dog Information

The Belgian Tervuren is a medium sized, elegant square standing herding dog that originally comes from Belgium. She was bred to protect flocks from wolves and other predators. She is fearless and can be quite aggressive. She needs an experienced handler. The optimal housing for her is indoors to be with the family with access to a large properly fenced yard or run. She needs plenty of exercise. She needs to be extensiviely socialized when very young. She like to chase joggers, cars and anything moving away from her due to her herding instinct so care must be taken if she gets loose. She can be very good with children but care must be taken with your childrens friends. As a reminder, no child should be left alone with any puppy or dog for any length of time. She does not like rough housing. She makes a great watch dog and guard dog.

*Approximate Adult Size. The approximate adult size (two years old or older) of the male Belgium Tervuren is 24 to 26 inches at the withers (highest point of the shoulder) and 65 to 75 pounds. Females range between 22 and 24 inches at the withers and weigh 60 to 70 pounds.

*Special Health Considerations. All dog breeds have certain inherited health problems associated with that specific breed and the Belgium Tervuren is no exception. Be on the lookout for epilepsy (common in dogs), eye problems, canine hip dysplasia (genetic based looseness in the hip joint that can lead to arthritis pain and lameness) and excessive shyness and aggressiveness.
*Grooming. The Belgian Tervuren has a long, harsh, straight coat and it lays flat. She should be brushed frequently. She is a shedder and brushing will help keep her environment free of shed hair. Brushing will help her maintain a clean and healthy coat and also help you keep a closer eye on her health and strengthen your emotional bond with your pet. She will also require some trimming.
Her teeth should be brushed at least twice a week with toothpaste and toothbrush designed for dogs. Brushing removes the accumulation of plaque and tartar which can cause cavities (rarely) and periodontal disease. Dog periodontal disease can lead to pain, loss of teeth, bad breath and other serious disease.
Her toenails may need to be examined for growth and clipped regularly. The toenails of the rear feet grow slower than the toenails of the front feet. Generally a guillotine type trimmer is the best for this chore and competent instructions to accomplish this can be found on the net.
*Litter Size: 6 to 10 Belgian Tervuren puppies.
*Life Span. The Belgian Tervuren can live between 12 and 14 years with proper nutrition, medical care and excellent living conditions.
*History. The Belgian Tervuren was developed in Belgium from a Belgian Shepherd line. These dogs were bred to protect flocks from predators such as wolves. They are intelligent, courageous and very aggressive. In France she is registered as part of the larger family of Chien de Berger Belge, but in the United States and some other countries they are broken out into four separate breeds, this one being Belgian Tervuren.
*Some Registries:
American Belgian Tervuren Club
UKC United Kennel Club
NKC National Kennel Club
CKC Continental Kennel Club
APRI Americas Pet Registry Inc.
AKC American Kennel Club
FCI Federation Cynologique Internationale
NZKC New Zealand Kennel Club
KCGB = Kennel Club of Great Britain
ANKC = Australian National Kennel Club
ACR = American Canine Registry

Litter Size: 6 to 10 Belgian Sheepdog puppies

Category: Herding, Sheepdog Family

Terms To Describe: intelligent, courageous, elegant, grace, power, smart, watchful, obedient,

*SPECIAL GOOD POINTS
Excellent watch dog.
Excellent guard dog.
Highly intelligent.
Fast learner.
Will prefer cool climates.
She is full of life.
*SPECIAL BAD POINTS
Can be very aggressive.
May not tolerate rough housing.
May want to chase cars, joggers and anything that appears to be moving away from her.
She needs an experienced owner.
She needs extensive socialization from an early age.
Can tend to be a one or two person dog.
She needs to be part of the family.
She needs a lot of exercise.

*Other Names Known By: Tervuren, Chien de Berger Belge

Mitch Endick is a short article writer, editor and website developer for the popular pet site petpages.com.
www.petpages.com is a pet information site with free pet ads, dog classifieds, and puppy for sale info Petpages.com also offers information on cats, fish, reptiles, birds, ferrets, rabbits, mice and even pet bugs.

Belgian Malinois Dog Breed Essential Information

Belgian Malinois Dog Breed Essential Information

The Belgian Malinois is a large intelligent dog that requires plenty of space. They are not suited to an apartment as they need a large properly fenced in enclosure to keep them exercised. They are an elegant well muscled dog, intelligent and eager to work. They will guard the family and make a great watchdog. They are good with older children but may not be good with your childrens friends. Just a reminder, never leave any young child unsupervised with a puppy or dog for any length of time. They may not take to other dogs and pets but can often be socialized to accept them.


*Approximate Adult Size. The approximate adult size (two years old or older) of the male Belgian Malinois is approximately 24 to 26 inches to the withers (highest point of the shoulder) and weigh about 65 to 75 pounds. Females are approximately 22 to 24 inches at the withers and weigh approximately 55 to 65 pounds.


*Special Health Considerations. All dog breeds have certain inherited health problems associated with that specific breed and the Belgian Malinois is no exception. Look for epilepsy (common in dogs), eye problems, canine hip dysplasia (genetic based looseness in the hip joint that can lead to arthritis pain and lameness) and excessive shyness.


*Grooming. The Belgian Malinois has an easy short hair coat. She should be bathed rarely as this strips her coat of its protective oils. She should be brushed at least weekly. She is a light shedder and brushing will help keep your house free of shed hair. Brushing will help her maintain a clean and healthy coat and also help you keep a closer eye on her health and strengthen your emotional bond with your pet.


Her teeth should be brushed at least twice a week with toothpaste and toothbrush designed for dogs. Brushing removes the accumulation of plaque and tartar which can cause cavities (rarely) and periodontal disease. Dog periodontal disease can lead to pain, loss of teeth, bad breath and other serious disease.


Her toenails may need to be examined for growth and clipped regularly. The toenails of the rear feet grow slower than the toenails of the front feet. Generally a guillotine type trimmer is the best for this chore and competent instructions to accomplish this can be found on the net.


*Life Span. The can live between 12 and 14 years with proper nutrition, medical care and excellent living conditions.


*History. The Belgian Malinois is a variety of the Belgian Shepherd dog from Belgium. The American Kennel Club recognized this breed on July 10, 1990. Today these dogs are used for military and police work because they are fast learners, willing to work, intelligent and aggressive.


Some Registries:


American Belgian Malinois Club


*UKC United Kennel Club


*NKC National Kennel Club


*CKC Continental Kennel Club


*APRI Americas Pet Registry Inc.


*AKC American Kennel Club


*FCI Federation Cynologique Internationale


*NZKC New Zealand Kennel Club


*KCGB = Kennel Club of Great Britain


*ANKC = Australian National Kennel Club


*ACR = American Canine Registry


Litter Size: 6 to 10 Belgian Malinois puppies.


Category: Herding, Sheepdog Family


Terms To Describe: Elegant, well muscled, proud, obedient, loyal,


*SPECIAL GOOD POINTS


Very intelligent.


Little grooming needed.


Responds well to commands.


Good with family children.


Very good watch dog.


Very good guard dog.


*SPECIAL BAD POINTS


Can be very aggressive.


Owner should be an experienced dog owner.


May not be good with your childrens friends.


Needs early proper training to curb aggressiveness.


*Other Names Known By: Malinois, Chien de Berger Belge

For more information on the Belgian Malinois or a full list of dog breeds take a look at this Dog Training website.

Find More Dog Eye Problems Articles